We Updated Our List of the Best Cream Soda (Red Cream Soda, Too) (2024)

By Gwynedd Stuart |

We Updated Our List of the Best Cream Soda (Red Cream Soda, Too) (1)

The best cream soda is a shot of nostalgia straight to the dome. Whether you say cream soda or creme soda like a fancy boy, this classic carbonated bev is a sweet delight. Even though most of us didn’t grow up in an era when we’d ride our Schwinn Stingrays down to the sodie fountain for a drink and a pocketful of penny candy, cream soda can make you feel like you did. It’s like childhood in a bottle, minus the trauma.

Our previous ranking of the best cream soda brands focused on the classic stuff, but for this taste test we wanted to broaden our horizons a bit. Now you can find the best orange cream soda and the best red cream soda on this list (spoiler: It isn’t Big Red). We judged them on their faithfulness to the classic cream soda profile—we want to taste actual vanilla in there, but we also want some nuance, too. Cream soda shouldn’t just be sweet; it should be fizzy and round and not so cloying that you can’t down a whole bottle or can of the stuff. If you’re looking for depth of flavor and that classic creamy-minus-the-actual-cream taste and mouthfeel, you’re going to find something great on this list of the best tasting cream soda.

The following article contains affiliate links that may generate a small commission to us when you make a purchase through the link. Learn more about how we work with affiliates here.

We Updated Our List of the Best Cream Soda (Red Cream Soda, Too) (2)

Best Diet Cream Soda

A&W Zero Sugar Cream Soda

Since sugar is such a big part of the cream soda flavor profile, finding a palatable sugar-free version isn’t easy. But we did it. Because we care. If you’re a diet soda guy, A&W makes the best diet cream soda at the grocery store. Unlike a lot of other diet cream soda, this stuff has actual depth and dimension. As my colleague Justine Sterling put it, “It actually tastes like cream soda rather than diet cotton candy soda.” It’s rare that a diet soda isn’t immediately recognizable as a diet soda, but A&W pulls it off, and that makes it the best diet cream soda we tried.

Credit: Liv Averett / Ralphs

Rating:

7.5/10

Sporks

We Updated Our List of the Best Cream Soda (Red Cream Soda, Too) (3)

Best Red Cream Soda

Kroger Big K Red Cream Soda

I know Big Red has a big fanbase, especially in Texas, but it’s not the best red cream soda we tried in our taste test. It’s good, but if you have a Kroger (or a Kroger-owned grocery store) in your area, try this Big K Red Cream Soda. It tastes almost exactly like Big Red—sweet and syrupy with a more bubble gum-adjacent flavor profile than the rest of the best cream soda on this list—but it’s a little more fizzy, and that extra fizz goes a long way when it comes to cutting the thick, sugary flavor. If you grew up on Big Red, you might like its lack of fizz, but it just wasn’t bubbly enough for our taste testers (we tried it from a plastic 20 ounce bottle). Big K nails the flavor but makes a soda that’s more drinkable overall.

Credit: Liv Averett / Kroger

Rating:

8/10

Sporks

Teddy’s Orange Cream Soda

Teddy’s Orange Cream Soda is delicious, but I also recognize that even the best orange cream soda is a bit of a departure from the classic cream soda flavor profile, so it ranks a little lower on our list. That said, this stuff perfectly balances its two flavor components. You get orange and cream in pretty much equal measure, but that deep vanilla creaminess shaves the edges off the orange soda flavor. If you’ve ever wanted to drink a carbonated creamsicle, this is your jam.

Credit: Liv Averett / Instacart

Rating:

8.5/10

Sporks

We Updated Our List of the Best Cream Soda (Red Cream Soda, Too) (5)

Best Sweet Cream Soda

IBC Cream Soda

Some people (like me) prefer a dryer cream soda. If you’re in that camp, see #3 on our list. But if you’re looking for the best cream soda that really brings that decadent, sugary sweetness, look no further than IBC Cream Soda. It’s made with cane sugar, and that clean sweetness really complements the pure vanilla flavor. This cream soda has a good, strong flavor and a single sip will put you in a good mood. Even if your preferences are more in line with mine, this is a nice once-in-a-while treat.

Credit: Liv Averett / Amazon

Rating:

8.5/10

Sporks

We Updated Our List of the Best Cream Soda (Red Cream Soda, Too) (6)

Best Caramel Flavor

Shasta Creme Soda

I tend to think of Shasta as a budget soda brand, but this cream soda has a really rich, toasty, almost caramel-y flavor that makes it taste way more expensive. Even though the head dissipates pretty quickly when you pour this soda into a glass, the powerful vanilla flavor contributes some ice cream-style creaminess to the experience. If you’re looking for the best cream soda to make an ice cream float with, try this one with a scoop of something creative. I’m going with a tart, tangy sherbet.

Credit: Liv Averett / Amazon

Rating:

9/10

Sporks

We Updated Our List of the Best Cream Soda (Red Cream Soda, Too) (7)

Best Fizz

New York Seltzer Vanilla Cream Soda

If this list of the best cream soda were based strictly on my personal preferences, New York Seltzer’s Vanilla Cream Soda would probably be in the top spot, and not just because I have fond childhood memories of the brand. It has a milder flavor than a lot of the other cream sodas we tried, which I can see turning off people who are looking for a bold soda taste, and it’s not as cloyingly sweet either, which I personally love. But what makes this one extra refreshing is that it contains small bubbles and highly active carbonation. This soda really dances on your tongue—and it comes in a small, adorable bottle. If you’re not super attached to a super sweet cream soda experience, you can’t miss with this one.

Credit: Liv Averett / Amazon

Rating:

9.5/10

Sporks

We Updated Our List of the Best Cream Soda (Red Cream Soda, Too) (8)

Best Vanilla Flavor

Faygo Vanilla Creme Soda

Faygo is leaning into vintage vibes with its throwback packaging, and it’s a pretty good look, albeit less friendly to a Juggalo aesthetic. Anyway, if ICP’s fandom gave you the impression that this wasn’t a classy soda brand, it’s time to reevaluate! Beyond the downright beautiful bottle, Faygo Vanilla Creme soda has the richest vanilla flavor of all the cream sodas we tried. I also think there’s something highly appealing about a clear cream soda. Faygo makes the best cream soda if you like a very vanilla-forward flavor.

Credit: Liv Averett / Soda Pop Shop

Rating:

9.5/10

Sporks

We Updated Our List of the Best Cream Soda (Red Cream Soda, Too) (9)

Best of the Best

Boylan Creme Soda

Boylan is one of our favorite soda brands—their black cherry soda made a strong showing in our first annual Burp Bracket. Boylan totally nails that delicate alchemy of vanilla flavor and fizz. It even smells delicious from the moment you crack open the lid. The secret could be the real cane sugar Boylan uses in its sodas, which gives it a crisp, natural flavor. I’m doing my best to explain it, but suffice it to say, this soda just tastes exactly the way it’s supposed to. It’s the best cream soda we tried in two separate taste tests.

Credit: Liv Averett / Amazon

Rating:

10/10

Sporks

Other products we tried: Diet Dr. Brown’s Cream Soda, Great Value Diet Cream Soda, Jones Cream Soda, Dad’s Cream Soda, Virgil’s Zero Sugar Cream Soda, A&W Cream Soda, Diet Shasta Cream Soda, Sprecher Cream Soda

Hot Takes

“Seafood And Dairy Don’t Go Together” And Other Food Rules We Should Rethink

By Jordan Myrick |

Rankings

The Best Chili Crisp for a DIY Dumpling Shop at Home

By Jordan Myrick |

Listicles

The 5 Best Things We Ate in June

By Ariana Losch |

We Updated Our List of the Best Cream Soda (Red Cream Soda, Too) (13)

About the Author

Gwynedd Stuart

Gwynedd Stuart, Sporked’s managing editor, is an L.A.-based writer and editor who spends way, way too much time at the grocery store. She’s never met an Old El Paso taco or mozzarella stick she didn’t like.

Your thoughts.

  • We Updated Our List of the Best Cream Soda (Red Cream Soda, Too) (14)

    Sara Owens

    Sprecher’s Cream Soda should be number 2 if not tied for number one with Boylan on this list.

    Reply

  • We Updated Our List of the Best Cream Soda (Red Cream Soda, Too) (15)

    Tim Cigelske

    I’m biased (I work at Sprecher) but I recommend trying Sprecher Cream Soda – you can see one of our 5 star reviews for why people love Sprecher Cream Soda!

    Reply

We Updated Our List of the Best Cream Soda (Red Cream Soda, Too) (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Gov. Deandrea McKenzie

Last Updated:

Views: 5397

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (46 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Gov. Deandrea McKenzie

Birthday: 2001-01-17

Address: Suite 769 2454 Marsha Coves, Debbieton, MS 95002

Phone: +813077629322

Job: Real-Estate Executive

Hobby: Archery, Metal detecting, Kitesurfing, Genealogy, Kitesurfing, Calligraphy, Roller skating

Introduction: My name is Gov. Deandrea McKenzie, I am a spotless, clean, glamorous, sparkling, adventurous, nice, brainy person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.